
I know this topic gets discussed over and over but sometimes I just can’t resist getting out my stick when I see a dead horse. The more I involve myself with various online discussions and blogs, the more I become annoyed by the constant disparaging remarks regarding the use of Photoshop and other post processing software. It usually goes something like “this is my picture. It looks great and I didn’t even use Photoshop” or “using Photoshop to enhance a photo makes the picture a lie”. There are a couple of serious problems with these arguments. First, if making adjustments to a photo after it has been taken isn’t legitimate then most of the photography from the last 100 years is junk. I would strongly advise a quick read of Ansel Adams’ books “The Negative” and “The Print”. In today’s world of digital photography, most of the methods presented in these books are of little use but they do give quite a bit of insight to the types of processes photographers used in the days of darkrooms.
Second, I am curious to know which settings they use on their cameras. People that make these arguments might be surprised to know that none of the files that come out of a digital camera are free from some type of processing. It is required to get from a digital capture to something we recognize as a photo. What should my white balance and dynamic range be set to in order to keep my photographs honest? What about any color space settings, sharpening, or noise reduction? The choice isn’t really between post processing and not, but between the questions of “am I going to do my own post processing” or “will I leave it in the hands of a camera engineer that I haven’t ever met and can’t possibly create an algorithm that understands my creative vision”. I think I will opt for doing things on my own.
Let’s be honest. Not all post processing work is created equal and sometimes it should be avoided altogether. Photos that are full of artifacts aren’t much fun to look at, at least in my opinion, and I don’t think you will get much of an argument over whether or not photos taken for photojournalistic purposes should be altered. But post processing is a skill in its own right and a skill that I feel is essential to the overall craft of photography. You can opt to take your photos straight out of the camera and, if that fulfills your creative vision, I can respect that. All I’m asking is for a little of the same respect in return. The choice of whether or not to use Photoshop should be up to me. It is a skill that I work hard at and if “Photoshopper” is a title then it’s one I will wear as a badge of honor.